Key takeaway
ShiftTracker is the better fit for UK security agencies, cleaning companies and FM firms: it holds BS 7858 screening records, SIA licence tracking, check calls and NFC patrol forms in one system, with published pricing and a 30-day free trial. Planday suits hospitality, retail and healthcare teams that need general shift scheduling with no sector compliance.
If you run a UK security agency, cleaning company, or facilities management firm, you need workforce software that handles your specific compliance obligations. ShiftTracker and Planday both manage rotas and timesheets. One is built for UK security and cleaning operations with BS 7858 screening records, SIA licence tracking with expiry alerts, and check-call monitoring built in as core features. The other targets hospitality, retail, and healthcare teams with general shift scheduling and no sector-specific compliance depth. This comparison answers which platform fits which operation, with specific attention to the compliance features that matter most when you are managing SIA-licensed officers or multi-site cleaning contracts.
Use ShiftTracker if: you need BS 7858 screening records, SIA licence tracking, check calls, NFC patrol forms or multi-client coordination as part of day-to-day operations.
Use Planday if: you run a hospitality, retail or healthcare team with no security or cleaning compliance requirements and need general shift scheduling.
What the two platforms are for
ShiftTracker is workforce management software built specifically for UK security agencies, cleaning companies, and FM operators. It covers BS 7858 screening records, SIA licence tracking with expiry alerts, check-call monitoring, patrol and incident forms, and multi-site scheduling. Payroll goes to Sage 50 or BrightPay as a file, or to Xero as draft timesheets. The design centre is the mid-market UK operation with compliance obligations, not generic shift scheduling.
Planday is shift management software owned by Xero. It targets hospitality, retail, healthcare, entertainment, and fitness teams. The platform covers rota scheduling, time and attendance, leave management, and payroll reporting with an optional Xero integration. There are no BS 7858, SIA, check-call, patrol, or security-specific compliance features. Planday's compliance monitoring covers general Working Time Regulations, not UK security or cleaning sector requirements.
Scheduling and rota management
ShiftTracker handles multi-client scheduling across security and cleaning contracts. You can run separate rotas for each client, assign officers or cleaners to site-specific shifts, and manage coverage across multiple locations from one dashboard. A broadcast offers an open shift to the employees you choose, and the first to accept is assigned. Each client can have its own portal login, with a scorecard of coverage, check calls, hours and incidents across its sites. For a full walkthrough of how multi-client scheduling works in ShiftTracker, see the multi-client scheduling setup guide.
Planday provides rota scheduling with drag-and-drop shift building, conflict detection, and availability management. Teams include hospitality, retail, and healthcare workers. The scheduling engine handles general workforce scheduling without sector-specific constraints. Open shifts can be published to a roster for staff to pick up.
Compliance features for UK security and cleaning
This is where the platforms diverge most significantly.
ShiftTracker embeds UK security and cleaning compliance as core workflows, not add-ons:
BS 7858 screening: a Screening tab for each person holds a five- or ten-year vetting window, employment and other periods, gaps of 31 days or more, the applicant's consent and references. DBS and credit checks are logged with the references, and the record exports to CSV.
SIA licences: each licence is recorded with its expiry date, with alerts before it lapses. Your team checks the public register by hand and the result is logged in the audit trail, and an expired verified licence stops the officer being rostered.
Check-calls: configurable intervals and windows, verified by PIN, site ID or GPS. A missed call alerts your control room in the app and by push, repeating every 10 minutes until acknowledged, and officers have a press-and-hold Emergency button. Every call is logged for audit.
Patrols: NFC, GPS and photo checkpoints run as forms, from ready-made library templates you can deploy to any site and adapt per client. Each scan records when and where it happened.
Incident reporting: ready-made incident, fire and accident (RIDDOR) report forms, with photos, signatures and a review step.
Planday's compliance features cover general employment law:
Working Time Regulations 1998: leave entitlement tracking, rest break compliance, maximum working hours monitoring against UK statutory limits.
No security-specific compliance: no BS 7858, no SIA licence checking, no check-call monitoring, no patrol tracking, no lone worker features.
Payroll compliance: timesheet data exports to Xero for payroll processing. No automated licence or certification checks.
Time and attendance
ShiftTracker records book-on and book-off in the mobile app, with GPS logged where the site is geofenced or the shift pattern asks for it. For cleaning teams working across multiple client sites, attendance is tracked per site and per shift. Shifts that drift from the rota are flagged in Payroll Arbitration for a person to decide.
Planday captures clock-ins via the employee app or Kiosk mode. Time and attendance data feeds into rota management and payroll reporting. The platform handles general attendance tracking without sector-specific rules.
Payroll integrations
ShiftTracker's Payroll Export builds a Sage 50 timesheet file, a BrightPay file or a generic hours file from approved shifts, split into basic, overtime and bank holiday hours, or sends draft timesheets to Xero. Client invoices come from the same arbitration records and can be sent to Xero as drafts on the Professional plan, so nothing is rekeyed.
Planday is owned by Xero. The native Xero integration is a core differentiator for hospitality and retail businesses already using Xero Payroll. Planday Starter and Plus plans both include Xero integration. The integration covers timesheet data and payroll reporting for standard employment types. For businesses already using Xero, the Xero and Sage payroll integration guide covers how ShiftTracker connects to both platforms.
Pricing
Planday pricing is tiered by user count and plan level:
Starter: £2.99 per user per month, minimum 5 users
Plus: £3.99 per user per month, minimum 10 users
Pro: custom pricing, quote-based
All plans include rota scheduling, time and attendance, leave management, and the Xero integration. The Pro plan adds advanced features including AI scheduling and workforce analytics.
ShiftTracker publishes its price: £49 a month plus £3 for each active employee, meaning someone who worked that month, so staff who did no work cost nothing. Professional adds £1.50 per active employee, and Enterprise, above 500 active employees, is agreed in writing. There is a 30-day free trial with no card.
Industry fit
Choose ShiftTracker if you:
Run a UK security agency with SIA-licensed officers and BS 7858 vetting obligations
Manage a cleaning company with mobile teams across multiple client sites
Need check-call monitoring, patrol forms or incident reporting as operational requirements
Co-ordinate staff across several client contracts and need per-client reporting
Choose Planday if you:
Run a hospitality, retail, healthcare or fitness business with no sector-specific compliance obligations
Need general shift scheduling with Xero payroll integration
Manage teams without BS 7858, SIA, check-call or patrol requirements
Summary
ShiftTracker and Planday serve different parts of the UK workforce management market. ShiftTracker is built for security agencies, cleaning companies, and FM operators where BS 7858 screening, SIA licence tracking, check calls and patrol forms are part of normal operations. Planday is shift management software for hospitality, retail, and healthcare teams with general compliance needs and existing Xero integration requirements.
If your operation involves SIA-licensed officers, multi-site cleaning contracts, or compliance workflows that go beyond the Working Time Regulations, ShiftTracker covers those requirements natively. If you manage hospitality staff with no security or cleaning obligations and already use Xero, Planday's pricing structure and Xero integration make it a direct fit.
Frequently asked questions
- Does Planday support SIA licences or BS 7858 screening?
- No. Planday's compliance features cover general employment law such as the Working Time Regulations. ShiftTracker records SIA licences with expiry alerts and holds a BS 7858 Screening tab for each person.
- How much does ShiftTracker cost compared with Planday?
- ShiftTracker publishes its price: £49 a month plus £3 for each active employee, meaning someone who worked that month. Professional adds £1.50 per active employee, and Enterprise, above 500 active employees, is agreed in writing. There is a 30-day free trial with no card. Planday lists Starter at £2.99 and Plus at £3.99 per user per month.
- Can ShiftTracker export payroll to Xero or Sage?
- Yes. Payroll Export turns approved shifts into a Sage 50 timesheet file, a BrightPay file or a generic hours file, or sends draft timesheets to Xero. On the Professional plan, client invoices can also be sent to Xero as drafts.
- Does ShiftTracker check SIA licences automatically?
- No. ShiftTracker records each licence with its expiry date and alerts you before it lapses. Your team checks the public SIA register and records the result, and every check is written to the audit trail. A licence held as a verified document also stops the officer being rostered on a shift after it expires.
- How does ShiftTracker handle a missed check call?
- ShiftTracker runs check calls in its app on an interval you set, verified by PIN, site ID or GPS. A missed call alerts your Admin and Control users and the site's managers in the app and by push, and repeats every 10 minutes until someone acknowledges it. Officers also have a press-and-hold Emergency button. ShiftTracker does not phone the worker.

